HomeUncategorizedethical dilemmas in mental health

By. Explore ways in which the nursing profession might improve its advocacy of people with mental health problems and severe mental illnesses. The moral force of the right’s claim in this instance is such that if an attending health care professional does not uphold or violates the patient’s decision in regard to the treatment options considered, that patient would probably feel wronged or that an injustice had been done. In a UK study, whereas 89% of voluntary organisations and more than two-thirds of stakeholder groups surveyed thought that PADs were needed, only 28% of psychiatrists surveyed thought they were ( Atkinson et al 2004 ). Social workers take on a variety of responsibilities that should ultimately serve their clients' best interests. According to media reports, this act led to a psychiatrist certifying him as rationally incompetent, thereby enabling John McEwan to be treated (fed) against his will. The less experienced staff members on the ward disagree with this reasoning, however, and argue that, even though the patient’s psychiatric condition is deteriorating, and this is a preventable harm, the patient is nevertheless able to make an informed decision about this and therefore his wishes should be respected. People with serious mental illnesses can often experience periods of profound distress during which their capacity to make prudent and self-interested decisions about their care and treatment options can be seriously compromised. Health Details: One of the biggest I can think of is the duty to warn rule, which differs by state. An important problem here, particularly in psychiatric contexts, is that severe mental illness can significantly affect the capacities needed for competent decision-making (for instance, understanding, reasoning and applying values), and hence the ability generally of severely mentally ill persons to make sound decisions about their own wellbeing – including the need for care and treatment. The test of ability to understand , on the other hand, asks whether the patient is able to comprehend the risks, benefits and alternatives to a proposed medical procedure, as well as the implications of giving consent. These views have been underscored in an insightful essay by Stier (2013) who explores the fundamentally normative nature generally of assessing, diagnosing and treating mental illness – including determining whether something is a mental illness (which relies on normative judgments about ‘normal’ versus ‘deviant’ behaviour), irrational (which includes judgments about ‘impaired reality testing’), or harmful and distressing (which relies on value-laden judgments about whether something is ‘bad and dysfunctional’). Variously named ‘psychiatric wills’, ‘self-binding directives’ (SBDs), ‘advance directives’, ‘advance statements’, ‘advance agreements’, ‘advance instructions’, ‘crisis cards’ and ‘Ulysses contracts’, the idea of notifying treatment preferences in advance, or making a ‘psychiatric will’ (a term that is analogous to ‘living wills’), is credited with originating in the work of the eminent American psychiatrist, Thomas Szasz (1982) , and the identified need for psychiatric patients to have an instrument that enabled them to refuse unwanted treatment. A similar stance was taken in New Zealand with the Ministry of Health releasing its Rising to the challenge: the mental health and addiction service development plan 2012–2017 (New Zealand Ministry of Health 2012 ). Often they arise because the presence of mental disorders causes many patients to lack capacity to make decisions for themselves and to depend on clinicians to attend to their best interests in ethics and law. Mental health statement of rights and responsibilities ( Australian Government Department of Health 2012 : 3)). Autonomy means "self-rule" and involves the right of an individual to make choices that may go against a physician's treatment advice concerning treatment, or non-treatment, of an existing health issue. As discussed in the previous chapter under the subject heading ‘The analytic components and elements of an informed consent’, an essential criterion to satisfying the requirements of an informed consent is competency to decide . In the case of suicide risk, the grounds for not honouring a patient’s decision do seem at least prima facie stronger than possible grounds for overriding the decision of a patient who is only moderately depressed. The ethical standards that guide mental health professionals in their work often conflict with the ethical principles that guide business practices, such as those employed by MCO’s. 3, p. 143. Values such as support, autonomy, privacy, participation, and solidarity are at stake here: values that can be realised on behalf of the client in the context of home care. For example, in what is believed to be the first published national study of its kind, an Australian survey of 143 psychiatrists found that less than 30% supported PADs which involved treatment refusals (e.g. A cross‐cultural qualitative study of the ethical aspects in the transition from child mental health services to adult mental health services. 6 years ago. Social Media and Ethical Dilemmas for Behavioral Health Clinicians ; The Wounded Healer: Helping the Helping Professional ; Cultivating Greater Meaning and Purpose to Prevent Relapse "The Wide World of Sports..." Wagering ; ... social workers, mental health counselors, professional counselors, psychologists, and other helping professionals that are interested in learning about addiction-related matters. Health Details: Ethical issues in mental health care | Nurse Key.Health Details: For example, if a patient with severe mental illness decides to refuse hospitalisation, the extent to which an attending health professional is obliged morally to respect this decision will depend on how severe the risks to the patient are of not being hospitalised – for ... ethical dilemmas in behavioral health, › Url: https://www.healthlifes.info/mental-health-ethical-dilemmas-examples/ Go Now, › Get more: Ethical dilemmas in behavioral healthShow List Health, Health Details: For example, if a patient with severe mental illness decides to refuse hospitalisation, the extent to which an attending health professional is obliged morally to respect this decision will depend on how severe the risks to the patient are of not being hospitalised – for instance, whether a failure to hospitalise the patient will result in her or him suiciding, or will result only in her or ... ethical dilemmas scenarios in counseling, › Url: https://nursekey.com/ethical-issues-in-mental-health-care-2/ Go Now, › Get more: Ethical dilemmas scenarios in counselingShow List Health, Health Details: Similarly, mental health therapists must make ethical decisions about whether their personal knowledge or connection to a particular client may require referral to another therapist due to a role conflict. Patients and clinicians often dif-fer in the meaning they attach to psychiatric diagnoses, for example, and in their beliefs about the utility of psychotropic medication and/or psychotherapy. Hasman, A., Mcintosh, E. and Hope, T. 2008: Journal of Medical Ethics, › Url: https://ukdiss.com/examples/medical-ethical-dilemma-case-study.php Go Now, Health Details: and mental health? They argue in defence of this decision that the patient’s condition is deteriorating rapidly, and that if he does not receive the medication prescribed he will ‘spiral down into a psychiatric crisis’ (in other words a total exacerbation of his condition), which would be even more intolerable and harmful than the unpleasant side effects he has been experiencing as a result of taking the psychotropic drugs in question. In mental health treatment, ethical dilemmas may arise because of differences be-tween a clinician’s personal values and beliefs and those of the patient, even when both individuals have the same cultural heritage. Health Details: Ethical issues happen when choices need to be made, the answers may not be clear and the options are not ideal. All issues are discussed subjectively from my own value base. › Url: https://www.yourceus.com/pages/eth8383-section-nine-analysis-of-the-scenarios Go Now. This course applies to continuing education ethical requirements. To describe community-engaged research (CEnR) and how it may improve the quality of a research study while addressing ethical concerns that communities may have with mental health and substance abuse research. Comparable studies conducted in Australia and New Zealand have had similar findings. Rachael Mattice. Non-discrimination and social inclusion – encompassing the rights to: privacy and confidentiality; health, safety and welfare; equal opportunities to access and maintain health and mental health care, and other social goods; contribute to and participate in the development of social, health and mental health policy and services. The promotion of mental health and the prevention of mental illness – encompassing the responsibilities of governments and health service providers to: promote mental health; support, develop, implement and evaluate programs for preventing mental health problems and illnesses; support the ongoing development of comprehensive, flexible, integrated, and accessible community, primary health and hospital-based social support, health and mental health services. Mental health practitioners working with children and families must attend to several ethical concerns that do not typically come into play with adult clients. You have been working with a client for the last 3 months on rebuilding his life and re-integrating into society after having spent 6 years in prison for sex offences. The patient might contest this decision. Harry Frankfurt, ‘Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person’ (1971) 68(1) J Phil 5; Gerald Dworkin, The Theory and Practice of Autonomy (CUP 1988). In defence of his refusal, the patient argues ‘reasonably’ that the adverse side effects of the drugs he is being expected to take are intolerable, and that he would prefer the pain of his mental illness to the intolerable side effects of the drugs that have been prescribed to treat his mental illness. Rutenberg and Oberle (2008) point out that ethics is about how we should and should not act, which is based on one’s values. … It has long been recognised at a social, cultural and political level that people suffering from mental illnesses and other mental health-related problems need to have their moral interests as human beings protected from abuse and neglect, which, for a variety of reasons, are especially vulnerable to being violated. While drawing primarily on the Australian experience, this discussion nonetheless has relevance for nurses working in other countries. A second consideration is that many people with mental illness have experienced high rates of trauma during their lifetime. Prior to 2014 there seemed to be little optimism that PADs will be formally adopted in Australian jurisdictions as a legal mechanism for promoting and protecting the rights of mentally ill people to participate effectively in decision-making concerning their psychiatric care and treatment. For example, if a patient claims the right to make an informed consent concerning prescribed psychotropic medication or electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), this imposes on an attending health care professional a corresponding duty to ensure that the patient is fully informed about the therapeutic effects and the adverse side effects of the treatments in question as well as to respect the patient’s decision to either accept or refuse the treatment, even where the health professional may not agree with the ultimate decision made. This is in contrast with a non-patient or ‘other’-centred decision-making model, which would have as its rationale preventing harm to others , and which embraces an ethical framework ‘for deciding about others for others’ benefits ’ ( Buchanan & Brock 1989 : 327, 331). Results The study included a total of 160 participants. It is important to acknowledge that, despite their envisaged benefits, PADs are not without risk. Just what these criteria should be, however, and how they should be applied, is an extremely complex matter, and one that requires much greater attention than it is possible to give here. a proxy directive , in which a patient ‘appoints a surrogate decision-maker who has legal authority to make treatment decisions on behalf of the patient when incapacitated’ ( Srebnik 2005 : S42). However, patients are also vulnerable to clinicians as a result of their lack of autonomy, and there is a sad history of the abuse … › Url: https://journals.lww.com/co-psychiatry/Fulltext/2011/05000/Ethical_issues_in_mental_health_research__the_case.7.aspx Go Now. But what are PADs, and are they capable of achieving the outcomes that their proponents anticipate and expect? To this end, the document addresses the following eight domains: Inherent dignity and equal protection – encompassing the right of all people to respect the human worth and dignity of people with mental illnesses, and to support people who are mentally ill or intellectually disabled to exercise their rights when their own capacity to do so is impaired. All rights reserved | Email: [email protected]. This article includes a review of the literature as well as recommendations from an expert panel convened with funding from the US National Institute of Mental Health. These By. Further, they argue, if he is given the medication against his will, an even greater harm will follow: specifically, he will trust the nursing staff even less than he does already, and will be even less willing to comply with his oral medication prescription than he is now. Introduction. Basically, it asks whether a given choice is the product of ‘mental illness’ or whether it is the product of prudent and critically reflective deliberation. In one US study, for example, although 66%–77% of consumer respondents stated they would like to complete a PAD if given the opportunity and assistance to do so, only 4%–13% had actually done so ( Swanson et al 2006b ). The bodies workers could be members of, or registered with, may include: › Url: https://www.healthlifes.info Go Now. At four o’clock in the morning on 3 April 1986, John McEwan was found dead by his nursing attendant. The more experienced staff members in this case insist that the patient should be given his medication forcibly by intramuscular injection. To put this more simply, PADs stand to serve the basic functions of: prescription (advance consent to treatment options), proscription (advance refusal or rejection of treatment options), surrogate decision-maker designation 4 (identification and advance nomination of substitute decision-makers). The test of reasonable outcome of choice is again as it sounds, and focuses on the outcome of a given choice, as opposed to the mere presence or absence of a choice. The different stakeholders are confronted with the following dilemmas: c … Health Details: One way to improve our ethics is to example arguments on both sides of common ethical dilemmas.. For example, the WHO estimates that in the United States, the return on investment for improving mental health care delivery is roughly 4 to 1. Contributors consider what caregivers’ responses to patients’ mental health needs and patients’ perceptions of their own mental illness express about the values of our health care system and ... › Url: https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/issue/ethics-and-mental-health Go Now. These are used to help unravel ethical issues relating to patient autonomy. Specifically, Buchanan and Brock (1989 : 84–6) suggest that the whole issue hinges on: setting and applying accurately standards of competency to choose and decide; and. Physicians traditionally acted to benefit their patients based on their own judgments about patients’ … Indeed, the very nature of psychiatric illnesses can raise challenging questions about patient autonomy. Discussions of key ethical dilemmas in mental health care, including consent, trauma and violence, addiction, confidentiality, and therapeutic boundaries. In attempting to secure protection of the rights of the mentally ill from abuse and neglect, a human rights model of mental health care ethics has been adopted. Some ethical dilemmas are specific to mental health nursing and are seen rarely in other areas of practice 2.An involuntary commitment to care, or a decision made by a family member on behalf of the patient, is often made to protect the patient from harming herself or others. Share; Tweet; In practice, it is sometimes necessary for social workers to make a judgment call, and one needs to be sure they are choosing the best options to resolve issues wisely when encountering an ethical dilemma. For instance, there remains the problem of how to determine what is a harm, what is a low / minimal and high / maximal risk of harm, and who properly should decide these things – the answers to which involve complex value judgments. Thus, the right to make informed and self-determining decisions has the distinction of provoking controversy in the field – a controversy that has been classically described as: On account of the tension between patient autonomy and therapeutic paternalism in psychiatric contexts – and the extraordinarily difficult and sometimes tragic situation in which this has often placed people (consumers and caregivers alike) – advocates and commentators have searched for ways to reconcile or at least accommodate the opposing values at issue ( Dresser 1982 ). Staff on the ward in which he is an involuntary patient are divided about what they should do. It will be recalled that this incident resulted in the patient being left highly mistrustful of nursing staff and even less willing to comply with his prescribed oral medication. As Gert and colleagues (p 132) go on to explain, we need to appreciate that persons as such are ‘not globally “competent” but rather “competent to do X”, where X is some specific physical or mental task’. Currently almost two-thirds of the states in the USA have legal processes in place for allowing and managing PADs (Zelle et al 2015b). Rather, it tends to be only in cases of ‘treatment refusals, especially those that appear to be irrational, that the question of a patient’s competence most frequently and appropriately arises’ ( Gert et al 1997 : 142; see also Light et al 2016 ). The following are several common ethical dilemmas that nurses face while on the job. The … As the Mental Health Consumer Outcomes Task Force argued almost three decades ago (1991: ix): In March 1991, the Australian Health Ministers acknowledged and accepted the above viewpoint and adopted, as part of Australia’s national mental health strategy, the final report of the Mental Health Consumer Outcomes Task Force, titled Mental health statement of rights and responsibilities . In 2016, the American Medical Association adopted ethical guidance principles on both telehealth and telemedicine (Balestra, 2017).

Nursing Education Jobs Online, Supply Chain Manager Job Description Pdf, Taylormade Irons For Sale, Nikon Coolpix B500 Red, Casio Lk 260 Manual, Life Cycle Of Mulberry Silkworm, Lion Brand Date Night Yarn, Lumix S5 Price, Microsoft Azure Fundamentals Book Pdf, Benefits Of Total Quality Management Pdf,


ethical dilemmas in mental health — No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *